GMR Senior Associate Tom Giardina won a Philadelphia County jury trial in which Plaintiff sued alleging ongoing injuries related to a motor vehicle accident. Specifically, Plaintiff alleged left shoulder tearing as well as cervical and lumbar herniations. The defense argued that the objective testing only showed degenerative conditions unrelated to the accident at issue. Through subpoenas, prior medical records established pre-existing complaints which Plaintiff had denied during litigation. Ultimately, the jury concluded, unanimously, that Plaintiff did not meet her burden of proof.